| Rank | Jugador | Equipo | Goles |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Paul Mullin | Cambridge United | 32(8) |
| 2 | James Vaughan | Tranmere Rovers | 19(5) |
| 3 | Matt Jay | Exeter City | 18(4) |
| 4 | Conor McAleny | Oldham Athletic | 17(3) |
| 5 | Danny Johnson | Leyton Orient | 17(0) |
| 6 | Jamille Matt | Forest Green Rovers | 17(3) |
| 7 | Ian Henderson | Salford City | 17(2) |
| 8 | Carlos Mendes | Morecambe | 16(1) |
| 9 | Scott Quigley | Barrow | 15(5) |
| 10 | Jack Muldoon | Harrogate Town | 15(0) |
| 11 | Joe Ironside | Cambridge United | 14(2) |
| 12 | Ryan Bowman | Exeter City | 14(0) |
| 13 | Cole Stockton | Morecambe | 13(0) |
| 14 | Max Watters | Crawley Town | 13(0) |
| 15 | Conor Wilkinson | Leyton Orient | 12(0) |
| 16 | Carlos Mendes Gomes | Morecambe | 12 |
| 17 | Andy Cook | Bradford City | 11(0) |
| 18 | Devante Rodney | Port Vale | 11(0) |
| 19 | Jon Mellish | Carlisle United | 11(0) |
| 20 | Luke Norris | Stevenage | 11(3) |
| 21 | Aaron Collins | Forest Green Rovers | 11(4) |
| 22 | Tom Nichols | Crawley Town | 11(3) |
| 23 | Elijah Adebayo | Walsall | 10(0) |
| 24 | Tom Conlon | Port Vale | 10(3) |
| 25 | Davis Keillor-Dunn | Oldham Athletic | 10(0) |
| 26 | Jordan Bowery | Mansfield Town | 10(2) |
| 27 | Callum Harriott | Colchester United | 9(2) |
| 28 | Alfie May | Cheltenham Town | 9(0) |
| 29 | Abo Eisa | Scunthorpe United | 9(2) |
| 30 | Aaron Wildig | Morecambe | 9(0) |
| 31 | Elliott List | Stevenage | 9(0) |
| 32 | Kaiyne Woolery | Tranmere Rovers | 8(0) |
| 33 | Alfie McCalmont | Oldham Athletic | 8(0) |
| 34 | George Lapslie | Mansfield Town | 8(0) |
| 35 | Andy Williams | Cheltenham Town | 8(0) |
| 36 | Lewis Alessandra | Carlisle United | 8(2) |
| 37 | Joel Randall | Exeter City | 8(0) |
| 38 | Adam Phillips | Morecambe | 8(4) |
| 39 | Antoni Sarcevic | Bolton Wanderers | 7(0) |
| 40 | Jevani Brown | Colchester United | 7(0) |
| 41 | Liam Sercombe | Cheltenham Town | 7(2) |
| 42 | Wes Hoolahan | Cambridge United | 7(0) |
| 43 | Joshua Kayode | Carlisle United | 7(0) |
| 44 | Matty Dolan | Newport County | 7(5) |
| 45 | James Wilson | Salford City | 7(0) |
| 46 | Ashley Hunter | Salford City | 7(0) |
| 47 | Nathan Delfouneso | Bolton Wanderers | 6(0) |
| 48 | Caolan Lavery | Walsall | 6(1) |
| 49 | Danny Rowe | Bradford City | 6 |
| 50 | Lee Novak | Bradford City | 6(0) |
| 51 | Paul Lewis | Tranmere Rovers | 6(0) |
| 52 | Zak Dearnley | Oldham Athletic | 6(0) |
| 53 | Bahamboula | Oldham Athletic | 6(0) |
| 54 | Jamie Reid | Mansfield Town | 6(0) |
| 55 | Will Boyle | Cheltenham Town | 6(0) |
| 56 | Jake Taylor | Exeter City | 6(0) |
| 57 | Yann Songo'o | Morecambe | 6(0) |
| 58 | Jake Young | Forest Green Rovers | 6(0) |
| 59 | George Francomb | Crawley Town | 6(0) |
| 60 | Patrick Brough | Barrow | 6(0) |
| 61 | Scott Twine | Newport County | 6(0) |
| 62 | Padraig Amond | Newport County | 6(1) |
| 63 | Nicky Maynard | Newport County | 6(1) |
| 64 | Josh Gordon | Walsall | 5(2) |
| 65 | David Worrall | Port Vale | 5(0) |
| 66 | Kieron Morris | Tranmere Rovers | 5(0) |
| 67 | Michael Folivi | Colchester United | 5(1) |
| 68 | Carl Piergianni | Oldham Athletic | 5(0) |
| 69 | Conor Thomas | Cheltenham Town | 5(3) |
| 70 | Dan Kemp | Leyton Orient | 5(0) |
| 71 | Alfie Beestin | Scunthorpe United | 5(0) |
| 72 | Rhys Bennett | Carlisle United | 5(0) |
| 73 | Offrande Zanzala | Carlisle United | 5(1) |
| 74 | Ashley Nadesan | Crawley Town | 5(0) |
| 75 | Tilley | Crawley Town | 5(0) |
| 76 | Josh Kay | Barrow | 5(0) |
| 77 | Josh March | Harrogate Town | 5(3) |
| 78 | Aaron Martin | Harrogate Town | 5(0) |
| 79 | J. Scrimshaw | Newport County | 5(0) |
| 80 | Joss Labadie | Newport County | 5(0) |
| 81 | Brandon Thomas-Asante | Salford City | 5(0) |
| 82 | Rory Holden | Walsall | 4(0) |
| 83 | Dan Scarr | Walsall | 4(0) |
| 84 | Clayton Donaldson | Bradford City | 4(0) |
| 85 | Nathan Smith | Port Vale | 4(0) |
| 86 | Peter Clarke | Tranmere Rovers | 4(0) |
| 87 | Lenell John-Lewis | Grimsby Town | 4(1) |
| 88 | Stephen McLaughlin | Mansfield Town | 4(0) |
| 89 | Sam Smith | Cheltenham Town | 4(0) |
| 90 | Callum Wright | Cheltenham Town | 4(0) |
| 91 | Luke Hannant | Cambridge United | 4(0) |
| 92 | Jack Iredale | Cambridge United | 4(0) |
| 93 | Randell Williams | Exeter City | 4(0) |
| 94 | Archie Collins | Exeter City | 4(0) |
| 95 | John O'Sullivan | Morecambe | 4(0) |
| 96 | Nicky Cadden | Forest Green Rovers | 4(0) |
| 97 | Odin Bailey | Forest Green Rovers | 4(0) |
| 98 | Dior Angus | Barrow | 4(3) |
| 99 | Mark Beck | Harrogate Town | 4(0) |
| 100 | Josh McPake | Harrogate Town | 4(0) |
